Wednesday, October 10, 2012

CGAA Cinema: A Cottage on Dartmoor (Directed by Anthony Asquith, 1929)

“In a small-town hairdressing salon, a young barber, Joe (Uno Henning) is trying to court Sally, the beautiful manicurist (Nora Baring) and asks her out. She rejects him in favour of the security offered by an older, wealthier farmer. In a jealous rage Joe slashes the farmer with a razor and is sent to Dartmoor prison for attempted murder. He escapes over the moors to find Sally, who does not know if he has come to kill her or ask her forgiveness, and it's at this point that the film begins. The rest of the story is told in flashback.” (BFI Filmstore 2008)

“...though many filmmakers, Asquith apparently included, believed that silent storytelling had reached such a high level of refinement that mere chatter would never be enough to extinguish it.

This, of course, was not to be, but “A Cottage on Dartmoor” provides ample illustration of how elegantly and assuredly expressive silent film had become, and how hard it must have been to believe that this magnificent medium, then just over 30 years old, was doomed.” (Kehr 2007)

Anthony Asquith’s obscure, blackly comic A Cottage on Dartmoor is a triumphant last-hurrah of silent British cinema. A deceptively simple tale of sexual jealousy which takes inspiration, style and techniques from a number of international sources. Released in 1929, the film sits on the transitional cusp between silent and talkie in British Cinema. As a young Alfred Hitchcock earned critical and financial success with his sound thriller, Blackmail, A Cottage on Dartmoor announced it’s artistic and cinematic intention against the unreceding tide of new technology. It is a love letter to the medium of silent film which achieves its narrative ambitions through the use of moody cinematography, theatrical acting and stylistic editing.

The film famously opens on the bleak environment of Dartmoor. The cinematography paints the landscape as unrelenting and unliveable, a hellish place not of this earth – echoing the masterful civil war scenes in D.W Griffith’s controversial 1915 film, The Birth of a Nation, and later used to great effect in Charles Laughton's 1955 The Night of the Hunter, Nick Roeg’s 1971 Walkabout and the numerous adaptations of the Dartmoor-set The Hound of the Baskervilles. Asquith was a keen admirer of European Expressionist cinema and the opening shots – though grounded in the English countryside - establish the film early on as coming from a distinctly un-British taste. Tom Ryall presents the argument “ has numerous directorial touches which reflect Asquith’s immersion in European cinema, his interests in Expressionist film and montage cinema. Yet the film can also be linked to the narrative drive and movement of the American film and the opening sequence in particular is built on the basis of an alternating montage strategy traceable to Griffith” (Ryall 2005:40) The European styled cinematography and design permeates through the film. Though the opening shots are arguably the most memorable, the majority of the film is set within atmospheric interiors which seep with shadow and light - Sally’s cottage is the most striking, while the Barber shop contrasts the mundane and clinical with Joe’s descent into madness. Furthermore, the editing feels equally international, distinctly Soviet, clearly inspired by Eisenstein and Pudovkin – quick montages are used to heighten tension and present Joe’s mind fragmenting and spiraling out of control as his jealousy deepens.

The film’s most effective scene brings all this outside influence into a fantastic cinematic sequence. The scene, set in a cinema during the showing of a ‘Talkie’ film, makes a clever reference to the mediums own fragility but also presents a showcase of its unique qualities as an aesthetic  We never the see the film on show, instead the action is concentrated entirely on the faces of the audience as a bombastic musical sequence delivers incredible suspension as Joe sits in the shadows, stalking the dating couple. His jealousy becomes more deep-seated after each passing second, each single cut of an Eisenstein inspired montage sequence. Murder is preceded by the quaintness of cricket and lawn tennis, who would've thought such a thing possible. Delivered without a moment of dialogue it's proof cinema is allowed to flourish, pure image becomes transcendent of the medium.

The film is often favourably compared to the early works of Hitchcock and demonstrated the potential of Asquith to be one of the more visually inventive British filmmakers of his time. Sadly, his career became decidedly mundane as it developed but there’s no doubt A Cottage on Dartmoor remains a virtuoso piece of directorial panache. Just look at these sumptuous shots!

A Cottage on Dartmoor, opening stills


BFI Filmstore (2008) A Cottage on Dartmoor At: (Accessed 09/10/2012)

Kehr, D (2007) New DVDs: A Cottage on Dartmoor At: (Accessed 09/10/2012)

Ryall, T (2005) Anthony Asquith Great Britain: Manchester University Press


  1. Hi Tom, Did you watch the BFI Silent Britain documentary (dvd cover)? If so was it any good?

  2. The poster is the only I could find online, and it's for the Kino DVD release of the film, which I don't own. The one I've got is the 2008 BFI release which doesnt have the doc. I'm pretty the documentary is where I first head about this film though, it was on BBC4 a few years back.